There’s nothing better than a good matchup. George Foreman versus Muhammad Ali, milk versus cookies, Star Wars versus the other one that can’t be named. And that’s exactly what appeared to be happening in the latest batch of earnings reports, which looked like a battle royale for big box retailers, with key players facing their competitors. These closely watched reports each offered a look at how cash-strapped consumers are (and aren’t) spending in a darkening economic landscape. So, who won their apparent matches? Built different. In one corner, Home Depot. In the other, Lowe’s. Both are watched for their proximity to the housing market and homebuilding, neither of which have been doing especially well lately. In August, homebuilder sentiment in the US unexpectedly dipped to its lowest level in over two and a half years. Home Depot seemed unfazed by the low morale in housing, sticking to its full-year outlook. In its latest earnings report, the company said it still expects full-year total sales to climb by 2.8%. But is that confidence fully founded? This marks the second straight quarter of earnings misses for the home improvement retailer, and its Q2 2025 report was the first since May 2014 to miss on both earnings and revenue expectations, per CNBC. What do the big box earnings say about consumers?—NP |