‘AI-related’ layoffs may not be all they appear
The bots aren’t coming for your job. Yet.
• 4 min read
Last month, some major corporations announced their headcounts would start to fall like brittle tree leaves in a November rain. FICO, Barclays, and American Express, to name three, announced workforce cuts of 5% to 15%, and they all connected the job pruning to AI.
For example, on October 23 the Wall Street Journal reported that American Express was trimming around 3,500 roles, or 5% of its global workforce. Its CFO, Christophe Le Caillec, said in a CNBC interview that the company wanted to “reduce layers and increase spans of controls, so that we can automate and take advantage of AI in the coming quarters and the coming years.”
So far in 2026, across the broader US economy, employers cited AI as a rationale in around 20% of all layoff announcements as of October 31, equating to 121,401 lost jobs, according to research from search firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas. In comparison, for the whole of 2025, AI was mentioned in layoffs affecting 54,836 jobs, or 4.5% of the total.
Was it the beginning of something? The evidence, according to experts, belies the hype. Anxious scanners of headlines should take corporate layoff announcements with a grain of salt.
Looking for proof. There is “zero evidence” that AI is taking finance jobs, Peter Cappelli, management professor and director of the Center for Human Resources at Wharton Business School, told CFO Brew. He cited a March 2026 working paper from the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) based on a survey of around 750 senior finance executives and CFOs between November 2025 and January 2026. The researchers found a less than 0.4% expected decline in jobs due to AI in 2026. “In the near term, AI has not led—and is not expected to lead—to meaningful reductions in aggregate employment,” the researchers concluded.
“At the macro level, we aren’t really seeing evidence that AI is driving layoffs, and in fact, we aren’t seeing an increase in layoffs at all,” Glassdoor chief economist Daniel Zhao told CFO Brew. The latest figures from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) showed that 1.6 million people were laid off or discharged in September, slightly lower than the 1.8 million monthly average before the pandemic, Zhao said.
The finance and insurance sectors are rapidly adopting AI, but at the same time they’re being affected by the “low-hire, low-fire” job market, the Yale Budget Lab’s director of research Ryan Nunn, told us. “What I see in the data is that as adoption has risen over the last couple of years, there has been a little softening in hires in finance and insurance,” he said, but that “softening” also characterizes the broader labor market.
CFO Brew helps finance pros navigate their roles with insights into risk management, compliance, and strategy through our newsletter, virtual events, and digital guides.
By subscribing, you accept our Terms & Privacy Policy.
Any true AI-related job replacement will arrive slowly, Cappelli theorized. Doomsayers who predict massive amounts of job loss “understand what the [AI] tool could conceivably do, but they have no idea what work looks like,” he said, noting that LLMs can replace single tasks but not entire roles. “It doesn’t matter what is conceivable; it is what is practical,” he said. “And practical includes what is cost-effective.” AI “is making a difference in terms of productivity,” he said, but through a “messy” and often expensive process of redesigning work.
The real story? If AI isn’t yet taking finance jobs, then how should professionals parse those layoff announcements? Some of it’s just spin, Cappelli said. “It’s the kind of thing investors want to hear,” he stated.
“Executives are under pressure to show that they are investing in AI and actually getting value out of AI,” Zhao observed.
The announcements might also point towards a shift in the composition of the workforce, rather than a replacement of human workers by technology. “Many of the layoffs right now are not about direct job replacement and instead about resource reallocation,” Zhao said. For instance, he said, a company might choose to cut staff in one product area to divert funds to another where it plans to use AI more heavily.
“It’s not really anything about the skills that those workers have or whether those skills can be automated away,” he said. In fact, CFOs in the NBER study mentioned above expect a move “away from routine clerical work and more towards skilled-technical roles” among their employees, the researchers wrote.
CFOs “are starting to ask the right questions” about AI, Cappelli said, and that includes “a thorough assessment of what this is going to cost, which includes risk and cost of mistakes,” as well as an evaluation of whether any productivity gains are worth it.
“They’re starting to close the open checkbook,” he observed.
About the author
Courtney Vien
Courtney Vien is a senior reporter for CFO Brew. She formerly served as editor in chief of the Journal of Accountancy.
CFO Brew helps finance pros navigate their roles with insights into risk management, compliance, and strategy through our newsletter, virtual events, and digital guides.
By subscribing, you accept our Terms & Privacy Policy.