• 5 min read
New “inflators” may push CFOs to keep a tighter rein on providers and quality of care, experts say.

Ersinkisacik/Getty Images
When it comes to managing healthcare costs, you don’t have to reinvent the wheel, but you do have to make sure the wheel is working a lot better than it has been.
In case you haven’t heard, CFOs are in a tricky spot right now: Total health benefit cost per employee is expected to climb 8.2% on average in 2027, and that includes already-planned cost-reduction measures, according to a survey released in September from professional services firm Marsh. If execs sit around and twiddle their thumbs, costs are expected to rise 11%.
“It used to be that while costs would go up year over year, employers had a fairly good handle on what was driving those costs, what the degree of increase might be, and therefore could budget more effectively or put strategies in place to try and mitigate those increases,” Ellen Kelsay, president and CEO of Business Group on Health, said of the uniquely challenging moment.
Now, “we have seen for three years in a row that employers, as well as their consulting and health plan partners, have missed their own forecast and underestimated their forecast by a growing margin with each of the past three years,” she explained.
“That’s why CFOs are paying more attention, not only just because of the magnitude of the increase in spending on healthcare, but the degree of volatility,” she added.
Tried and true. For all the volatility, some things stay the same, and healthcare spending experts recommend considering underlying cost drivers for what they are: the baseline, and largely unchangeable.
Three main healthcare cost drivers “have always been here,” Simon Camaj, US health leader at professional services firm Marsh, pointed out: unit costs, utilization, and severity of illness and diagnosis. “The health plans, to a certain extent, underwrite, and say these are the three levers that we look at to underwrite and price,” he told CFO Brew.
Now, however, there are a host of new entrants driving costs, Camaj noted, citing everything from gene therapies and more severe illnesses to the use of AI in the medical field and the rise of GLP-1 usage.
“The new variables with the foundation [are] increasing [the] trend, which is now getting more attention,” he noted.
Hold partners accountable. But it’s not that former cost management strategies “don’t work anymore,” Kelsay said. Companies need to design cost management plans that wrangle “the new phenomena that are really driving this volatility” without abandoning tried-and-true strategies.
To that end, she recommends CFOs reinforce the effectiveness of their “foundational” cost management strategies, like “vendor performance and vendor accountability.”
With all the time, money, and resources that employers invest in health and well-being programs, “[CFOs] need to hold the feet to the fire of every vendor that they have partnered with to deploy health and well-being services to their workforce,” she said. “That could be a health plan, it could be their PBM, it could be their consulting partner.”
“If costs are going up and people are getting sicker, outcomes aren’t improving, and the patient experience is pretty subpar, then, in many ways, my partners are failing to deliver on the promise that they professed they would bring to their offering,” she said, adding CFOs may have to grow comfortable “replacing those vendors that are underperforming.”
“That’s vendor management 101, but with a real rigor around the accountability and outcomes, and being willing to disrupt a longstanding vendor relationship when they’re not delivering,” she said.
Shake it up. Given the new inflators driving healthcare costs, organizations sometimes will also need to rattle the foundation a bit, Mike Pasterick, health solutions practice leader for Aon North America, said.
“We’re in a new era where you really need to focus on utilization and mix to really bend the curve for your particular situation,” he told us. “Where are your people getting care? Why are they getting that care? And what are you paying for that care?”
That’s driving a “mind shift” among CFOs, who want to maintain the established “social contract” between employers and employees when it comes to benefits offerings, while also acknowledging that the relationship might have to become more directive.
The employee is “going to have to maybe go through processes for approvals before [they] get things, because we [the employer] need to know it’s necessary, and if it is necessary, we need to know that you’re going to a quality provider at an appropriate cost,” he said. “That is really the shift that’s happening now to try to change how employers are interfacing with their people.”
“Before you slash and burn the benefits,” Pasterick advises executives, “make sure that there are alternate paths. You have ways to steer people to lower cost sites of care that are of higher quality. You [can] potentially discontinue covering things you don’t have to cover if it doesn’t make sense for you, or introduce other prior authorization methods,” he said. “We’re at a point where, if I only have one more dollar, where am I going to spend it?”